'Clear this project is not the correct way forward' - Key figures react to Harrogate’s Gateway consultation

It revealed a slim majority of people are against it — but the overall picture is of a town that remains fiercely divided over the plans.

Since the project was first mooted three years ago, some members of Harrogate’s business community have raised concerns that it could put shoppers off from visiting the town.

Whereas groups like Harrogate District Cycle Action and Zero Carbon Harrogate believe fewer cars will enter the town to create a more pleasant and environmentally-friendly place to visit.

David Simister, chief executive of Harrogate District Chamber of Commerce, said he “recognises the need to encourage active travel” but that “it’s clear this project is not the correct way forward because the majority do not support it.”

Slim majority against Harrogate Station Gateway proposals as town remains divided

He said: “It is going to have a massive impact on town centre business, many of whom are vehemently opposed to the scheme as they believe it will have a detrimental impact on their livelihoods.

“We believe that all relevant stakeholders, including cycling groups, should collaborate and come up with a better solution, one that all parties can buy into and which will appeal to the majority, and ensure this investment is not lost.

“There are elements of the scheme such as improvements to the public realm the majority are in favour of, me being one, however 46% verses 44% said they do not support the scheme.”

Kevin Douglas, chair of Harrogate District Cycle Action said he hopes the project can now move forward.

“We’ve not seen all the detail but obviously more people responded this time which is a positive outcome,” he said. “We’re pleased that people think the scheme will result in a good use of public space and will be better for businesses.

Harrogate Gateway: Figures reveal how town feels about scheme following third consultation

“But the time for consultation has now come to an end and we need to get on with it. It’s controversial but this is moving forward. We’ve got to now leave it to the politicians who will make the decision.”

Harrogate Borough Council’s Conservative cabinet member for carbon reduction and sustainability, Coun Phil Ireland, said: "I am delighted to see the majority of people who responded agreed that the proposals would encourage walking and cycling in the town centre. I was also pleased to read constructive suggestions to improve the scheme, which I truly believe will support a sustainable future for Harrogate.”