Now protect henges for all time - call
HENGES campaigners are calling for more protection to ge given to the ancient site at Thornborough, north of Ripon, after quarry giant Tarmac announced it would challenge a decision blocking its expansion plans.
At a meeting in Masham on Tuesday, North Yorkshire County Council’s planning committee voted 6 - 3 to reject Tarmac’s controversial proposal to quarry 112 acres at Ladybridge Farm, close to the 5,000 year old henges.
The committee ruled against the application for an extension of the existing Nosterfield Quarry, saying it went against the county’s mineral local plan regarding location, scale and the adverse impact it would have on “nationally important archaeological remains”.
But before anti-quarry campaigners had time to celebrate their victory, Tarmac announced it would be appealing against the decision.
The firm’s estates manager, Bob Nicholson, said after the meeting: “We are deeply disappointed at this decision, which threatens the livelihoods of more than 50 people and has serious implications in respect of the supply of sand and gravel to the construction industry.
“We will appeal against this decision because we believe that the advice given by English Heritage is based on speculation and supposition about the status of archaeology at Ladybridge and their assertion of national importance is not supported by factual evidence.”
In response to the continued threat of quarrying near the henges, heritage action group TimeWatch has called for the recently proposed Thornborough Henges conservation plan to be radically redrafted to reflect the importance of the area.
Spokesman George Chaplin said: “The threat of quarrying has not been removed by the planning refusal but it has given time to take stock and for everyone to agree upon the best future for the whole area.”
The Timewatch proposals are for:
l a much wider “no quarry zone” extending at least a mile radius from the central monuments
l the preservation of all archaeology within the zone to be the top priority
Mr Chaplin said: “Tarmac have not given up in their ambition to extend the existing quarry. They intend to appeal against the refusal and the danger remains very real for the whole of the remaining surroundings.
“Tarmac’s reaction to Tuesday’s defeat and its insistence that English Heritage is wrong, should be seen as a warning to us all.”
Extensive archaeological excavations at Ladybridge led English Heritage to oppose any further quarrying in the area because because it was a site of national importance.
But Mr Nicholson insisted: “Our proposal for Ladybridge, which actually moves quarrying further away from the henges than our current operation, poses absolutely no threat to the ancient monument, which is protected by law.
“We maintain that our application is both justified and reasonable and we will mount a robust case for its approval at appeal, when we hope that factual evidence will prevail over mythical invention.”
Tarmac’s application had been hugely controversial, with anti-quarry campaigners winning international support to safeguard the setting of an ancient monument that has been named ‘The Stonehenge of the North’.
County Coun John Fletcher, who chaired Tuesday’s planning meeting, said: “This was a hard decision to reach, but the committee gave full consideration to the well articulated arguments from both sides before coming to their conclusion.”
Yorkshire Euro-MP, Edward McMillan-Scott, who visited Thornborough last year, said he was delighted with the council’s refusal of planning permission.
"This is the right decision,” he said “The henges are an enormously important site of international significance. The site deserves a visitor centre and the attention which Stonehenge receives. I am delighted and relieved and I pay tribute to the local campaigners for the henges who are a model action group."
Email to a friend
Print this page
Looking for...
Featured advertisers
Jobs
Search for a job
Motors
Search for a car
Property
Search for a house
Weather for Ripon
Sunday 05 February 2012
Today
Sunny
Temperature: 0 C to 6 C
Wind Speed: 8 mph
Wind direction: West
Tomorrow
Sunny spells
Temperature: -1 C to 5 C
Wind Speed: 8 mph
Wind direction: North west
